Payroll & employees

Employee or 1099 contractor in California: ABC and Borello explained

Review all three ABC conditions, the B2B criteria, Borello and separate IRS rules. An LLC, W-9, agreement, remote work or fixed fee does not determine status.

9 min read · Sources checked: November 16, 2026

Published by: First Level Consulting Inc. · Sources and editorial standards · Updated:

Calling someone a contractor is not simply a payment choice. When the actual relationship is employment, an independent-contractor agreement and a 1099 do not remove employer duties. A mistake can affect wages, payroll taxes, overtime, expenses and workers’ compensation. Examine the relationship, not just paperwork.

A California business needs two separate reviews: the applicable state standard and the IRS rules for federal employment taxes. This guide organizes the facts. Individual status, exceptions and earlier periods require professional assessment.

Describe the actual work before the first payment

Document an ordinary working week. Who assigns tasks, sets hours, trains, controls methods and quality, deals with customers and approves breaks? Who negotiates prices, bears expenses, supplies equipment and has a genuine opportunity for profit or loss? Compare the written agreement with messages and daily practice.

A monthly fee, project price, sales commission, part-time schedule or personal laptop is not decisive. Employees can work remotely and earn commissions. Agreeing to a 1099, having an EIN or LLC, signing a W-9, issuing invoices or receiving no benefits does not automatically establish independence.

California ABC: establish A, B and C

When Labor Code §2775 applies, the starting presumption is employee status. The hiring entity must establish all three ABC elements. Passing A and C does not compensate for failing B: this is not a majority-of-factors score. Where an element is missing, first establish whether an applicable exception or special rule changes the test.

For C, the independent business must exist while the work is performed, not merely be possible in the future. For A, the contract and actual practice both matter. A right to direct performance can be relevant even when the business does not exercise it every day.

ElementPractical question
A · ControlIs the worker free from the hiring entity’s direction and control over performing the services, in both the contract and actual practice?
B · Usual businessIs the work outside the hiring entity’s usual course of business? Services the business sells to customers warrant careful review.
C · Independent enterpriseDoes the worker customarily operate an independent business of the same kind, offering services to the market and maintaining a business beyond this engagement?

Two businesses: why a B2B contract is insufficient

Labor Code §2776 provides a route for bona fide business-to-business relationships. The provider can be a sole proprietor, partnership, LLC, LLP or corporation. Besides qualifying parties, the contracting business must establish all 12 criteria. Satisfying them leads to Borello analysis, not automatic independent-contractor status.

The preparation map below follows EDD DE 231BB. Services generally must be provided directly to the contracting business rather than its customers. A narrow proviso covers the provider’s employees working under the provider’s name when that provider regularly contracts with other businesses. It is not a general outsourcing exception.

  • 1–2: freedom from control; services directly to the contracting business, subject to the specific proviso.
  • 3–4: a written agreement specifying the payment amount or applicable rate and payment due date; required business licensing or tax registration.
  • 5–6: a separate business location, possibly a home; an established independent business of the same kind.
  • 7–8: freedom to contract with other businesses and maintain customers without restriction; advertising and public availability.
  • 9–10: appropriate tools, vehicles and equipment, apart from necessary proprietary materials; ability to negotiate rates.
  • 11–12: ability to set hours and location consistently with the work; no CSLB-license-required work. Construction subcontracting requires its own applicable analysis.

Borello and professional exceptions

Some occupations and relationships have special standards, sometimes with additional conditions. Establish the particular exception before applying the resulting test. An exception from ABC is not a minimum-wage or overtime exemption for an employee: those are different questions.

Borello weighs the whole arrangement: the right to control methods, an independent business, skill, equipment, investment, financial risk, duration, payment method and the work’s role in the hiring business. It also starts with employee status presumed; the hiring entity must establish independence. No one factor decides status; the agreement and the parties’ beliefs do not settle it.

Beauty businesses need the appropriate license, actual independence and exception conditions. EDD explains that the licensed-manicurist exception was unavailable for 2025; AB 1514 reinstated it from January 1, 2026 through December 31, 2028 when requirements are met. Chair rental and last year’s conclusion are not sufficient.

IRS: a separate federal analysis

For federal employment taxes, the IRS generally examines behavioral control, financial control and the relationship: instructions and training; investment, expenses, market access and risk; and permanence, benefits and the role of the work. There is no magic number of facts guaranteeing a 1099. Statutory employees and statutory nonemployees have separate rules.

An IRS conclusion does not create a California exception, and a qualifying state B2B arrangement does not replace the federal review. W-9 collects payee information and 1099 reports payments when reporting rules apply; neither establishes lawful classification. Work performed in another state also requires review of that state’s requirements.

Four situations requiring careful review

These hypothetical examples identify questions, not individual determinations. Establish the governing test and every relevant condition even when one fact looks favorable. A separate service business and a worker effectively integrated into the team can appear similar on paperwork.

SituationWhat to examine
Remote administratorA helper uses the company phone, follows scripts and assigned hours, and is supervised. A personal laptop does not remove element A. Calling a job “HR” does not automatically create a professional-services exception.
Cleaning businessA company sells cleaning and sends helpers to customers, raising element B. Janitorial services are excluded from the particular referral-agency exception; this does not prohibit every genuine B2B arrangement.
Construction / handymanExamine work type, CSLB, Labor Code §2750.5 and construction-exception conditions. The general §2776 route excludes CSLB-required work. Having a license does not itself establish the other requirements.
Beauty / chair rentalReview the appropriate license, actual pricing, bookings, payment handling, independence and service year. Chair rent, commissions and a contractor agreement do not automatically decide status.

The consequences extend beyond a 1099

Misclassification can require correction of payroll taxes and reports, unpaid wages, overtime, meal/rest obligations, necessary work expenses, unemployment insurance and workers’ compensation. Interest, penalties and separate consequences for willful misclassification may apply; amounts depend on the facts.

Day rates, commissions and fixed fees do not remove applicable wage-and-hour duties. Explaining Schedule C deductions does not replace an employer’s duty to reimburse qualifying expenses. Workers’ compensation and commercial general liability are different coverage types, requiring a separate insurance review.

Organize payments after the review

For employees, coordinate employer identity, onboarding, time and expense records, payroll, withholding, payments, reports and insurance. A payroll provider calculates supplied information; it does not establish correct classification or employment terms.

For genuine contractors, retain agreements, invoices and work records; collect W-9 information securely and check the relevant year’s 1099 requirements separately. California DE 542 reporting can also apply. Filing a federal 1099 does not automatically satisfy it.

If you already paid someone as a contractor

Preserve agreements, messages, hours, payments and earlier forms, and identify affected workers and periods. Do not rewrite the history or assume another 1099 fixes it. Review earlier obligations, corrections and future arrangements with a tax professional and, for employment-law conclusions, appropriate counsel.

A firm or worker can request an IRS determination through SS-8 for federal employment taxes and income-tax withholding. EDD DE 1870 addresses California employment-tax and PIT-withholding status. Neither procedure automatically resolves every labor or insurance issue or cancels current obligations.

Reassess when duties, supervision or customer contact changes. DIR explains the wage-claim procedure for workers who believe they were misclassified. Establish the appropriate agency, process and deadlines before submitting records; no reliable classification or guaranteed protection follows without examining the facts.

What to prepare for a discussion

  • Actual duties, hours, training and rights of control.
  • Agreements, instructions, messages, hours, invoices and payments by period.
  • Customers, advertising, business location, equipment and worker expenses.
  • The specific exception and evidence for all its conditions.
  • Separate federal and California conclusions, work type and licenses.
  • A payroll, expense, insurance and correction plan.

Questions and answers

The worker wants a 1099. Can we agree?

Preference does not replace the applicable test. Review the relationship; statutory employee rights cannot simply be waived.

Does an LLC and personal laptop prove B2B status?

No. Establish qualifying parties, all §2776 conditions, and then Borello. The separate federal analysis remains necessary.

Does a fixed fee or commission mean contractor?

No automatic conclusion follows. Payment method is one fact; employees earning salary or commissions can retain wage-and-hour rights.

Can any beauty professional rent a chair and receive 1099?

No. The appropriate license, exception and actual independence matter. The service year is particularly important for manicurists.

Can we simply begin W-2 payroll next month?

Future onboarding and past periods require separate review. New payroll does not automatically resolve earlier taxes, wages or insurance obligations.

Official sources

Get an estimate Call us

Cookies and privacy

Google Analytics measures website visits. Google Ads and Meta Pixel support advertising and follow-up ads, with separate choices. Only with your permission. The site works without these tools.

Essential functions: always active

Operating and protecting the website, and remembering your privacy choices in this browser.

Google follow-up ads require both Analytics and Google Ads permission. Meta permission is separate.

Analytics preferences last up to 180 days. Advertising data-sharing opt-outs are retained separately; the site does not ask you to allow advertising again for at least 12 months. You can change your choice here.